ListenLarger documents may require additional load time.
The cost of quiet: 10 years in prison
Shotgun News. 65.9 (Mar. 20, 2011): p99.
Full Text: 

Second Amendment foes often claim they are looking for "common sense" restrictions and infringements on the right to keep and bear arms. But what passes for common sense often turns out to be the purest nonsense. Over the past few months I've been exploring some of the stupid gun laws already on the books; laws that have been around long enough to be just part of the background. But when we dig into them, it turns out that they are "Common Nonsense."

Most Americans perceive a silencer as a tool used by spies and mafia hit men to commit stealthy murders. That idea stems from fiction in books and movies. Although Suppressors are simple and inexpensive to construct, their use in crime is so rare as to be non-existent.

Even so, the penalty for possession of an unregistered silencer in the US is up to 10 years in prison and a $10,000 fine. This in spite of the fact that in many places around the world a silencer (or suppressor as they are called by aficionados) is considered just good manners. Indeed, in many countries the use of a suppressor is mandatory for hunting and most other shooting just as mufflers are required on cars and motorcycles.

Under current U.S. law silencers are treated exactly the same as machine guns. Their manufacture is tightly regulated and buying one requires payment of a special tax, a thorough background investigation, and permission from the local Sheriff or Chief of Police. Further, every part of a silencer is legally considered to be a silencer itself. So just possessing a single baffle (basically a washer) from a silencer is a federal felony carrying the same 10-year, $10,000 penalty.

All of this seems a bit harsh for possession of something which can be easily constructed from a plastic soda bottle and a bit of tape--or a fluffy pillow.

Any device that is designed or intended to reduce the noise of a firearm is itself considered a (restricted) firearm as are any part or parts of such a device--all because some politicians believed what they read in Mickey Spillane novels or saw in James Bond movies and couldn't figure out what legitimate purpose a silencer could have. Once these ignorant politicians passed their ill-conceived law, the bureaucrats got busy refining definitions and expanding their own authority. Today, as plastic suppressors with felt baffles are gaining popularity with air-gun shooters, the ATF has decreed that these devices could be attached to firearms and are therefore silencers--even though live ammo would quickly destroy them.

A Massachusetts man named Michael Crooker learned about this the hard way when he was arrested in 2004 and convicted in 2006 of unlawful possession of a silencer and related charges. He built the silencer for an air rifle and shipped the air-gun and muffler to a buyer in Ohio, but the shipment was intercepted by authorities.

Crooker was sentenced to 22 years in prison. Last year, after 6 years; behind bars, Crooker won his appeal of the decision, but he was not immediately released because a new charge had been brought against him--possession of ingredients to make weapons of mass destruction.

It seems that when authorities searched Crooker's home during the 2004 silencer investigation they found some castor beans and rosary peas, common legumes from which the poisons ricin and abrin can be derived. Can there be any doubt that something is terribly wrong with our "Justice System?"

Back to Silencers:

Hearing damage is the most common long-term injury to our soldiers and it is a much too common disability among shooters and hunters. Firing in indoor ranges and facilities with sound baffles designed to contain the noise so as not to disturb the neighbors exposes shooters to even higher noise levels. Wearing traditional hearing protection such as plugs and muffs makes it difficult to hear other things such as game (or enemies) in the field or important range commands.

Suppressors can help dramatically in all of these areas and also reduce the concerns of rural residents who are disturbed by the noise of their neighbors taking target practice on a Saturday afternoon. Suppressors also make teaching gun handling and range safety much easier and safer since the students don't have to have their ears plugged arid can hear what the instructor is saying.

Of all of the stupid gun laws on the books, laws restricting silencers are among the stupidest. The cliche says "Silence is Golden," but in the U.S. today silence is a felony. That's just nonsense.

From The Firearms Coalition

Permission to reprint or post this article in its entirety is hereby granted provided this credit is included. Text is available at To receive The Firearms Coalition's bi-monthly newsletter, The Knox Hard Corps Report, write to PO Box 3313, Manassas, Va. 20108.

[C]Copyright 2010 Neal Knox Associates--The most trusted name in the rights movement.

Source Citation   (MLA 8th Edition)
Knox, Jeff. "The cost of quiet: 10 years in prison." Shotgun News, 20 Mar. 2011, p. 99. General OneFile, Accessed 22 Feb. 2019.

Gale Document Number: GALE|A252741290