Second brother convicted in cross-burning case; Nova Scotia incident left family 'appalled and terrified'

Citation metadata

Date: Nov. 10, 2010
Publisher: Toronto Star Newspapers Limited
Document Type: Article
Length: 593 words

Document controls

Main content

Full Text: 

Byline: Michael MacDonald; The Canadian Press

There's little doubt racism was behind a young man's decision to burn a cross in front of the home of an interracial couple, a Nova Scotia judge declared Tuesday as he convicted Nathan Rehberg of publicly inciting hatred.

The guilty verdict, handed down in Nova Scotia's Supreme Court in Kentville, marked the second time in less than a month that the high court has registered a hate crime conviction - a legal rarity in Canada.

Last week, Rehberg's younger brother, Justin, was also convicted of inciting hatred in connection with the same incident in rural Poplar Grove, about 70 kilometres northwest of Halifax.

Supreme Court Justice John Murphy said he accepted the Crown's submission that on Feb. 21, just after midnight, Nathan Rehberg used a lighter to set fire to a 2.5-metre wooden cross, doused with some type of accelerant.

Murphy said testimony from Justin Rehberg, 20, confirmed Nathan had built the cross and later dragged it to the nearby home of Shayne Howe, who is black, and Michelle Lyon, who is white.

The judge said he also accepted the testimony of Howe's 18-year-old stepdaughter, Ashley, who told the court she saw the flaming cross and heard someone yelling racist slurs from the darkness.

"The incident engendered fear . . . and I'm satisfied that (the fear) was reasonable," Murphy said in his ruling.

He said the circumstances "give rise to the inevitable inference that racism was involved."

The judge also convicted the 21-year-old of criminal harassment, saying his actions left the teen and her parents "appalled and terrified."

At the time, four other children were in the home - one of them only two years old - but the judge said it wasn't clear whether they could comprehend what was going on.

It didn't matter that physical evidence in the case, including the cross itself, was thrown in the garbage by police, Murphy said.

The judge said discrepancies over how long the cross burned and whether there was a noose on it were also irrelevant to the case.

Nathan Rehberg had pleaded not guilty to the two charges during his two-day, judge-only trial.

Charges of uttering threats and mischief were dropped.

Immediately after Murphy delivered his ruling, Rehberg walked out of the courtroom, stopping briefly to talk to reporters about his pending sentencing.

"I'm nervous about what I'm going to get, but whatever it is, I deserve it," said Rehberg, a slight man with a scruffy beard, dressed in a dark hoodie and black jeans.

"I did the crimes so I got to do the time. It wasn't a racist act, but there was a lot of evidence to make it look like it was. I'm sorry if it was . . . I'm going to be a man and face the consequences."

Earlier, Nathan Rehberg said the cross burning was retaliation for comments Lyon had made, apparently alleging that the two men had a sexually transmitted disease.

Outside the courtroom, Howe said he was relieved the two trials were over.

"There's no reason to have hate against anybody," he said. "We are who we are."

Lyon said she was also pleased with the ruling, but she added that she and her family intend to move to another community.

"We've made that decision and that's final," she said.

Nathan Rehberg will be sentenced Jan. 10.

His brother, who pleaded guilty to criminal harassment, will be sentenced Dec. 14 on that and the charge of inciting hatred.

The Canadian Press

2010 Waterloo Region Record. All rights reserved.

Source Citation

Source Citation   

Gale Document Number: GALE|A241758023