Article Reading Levels
  • Level 3

Document controls

Is professional football: too violent? (News: Debate)

Citation metadata

Date: Jan. 10, 2003
From: Junior Scholastic(Vol. 105, Issue 10)
Publisher: Scholastic, Inc.
Document Type: Brief article
Length: 352 words

Main content

Full Text: 

Professional football players are often celebrated for their ability to hit, block, and tackle their opponents on the field.

To protect themselves, football players wear helmets, pads, mouthpieces, and other safety gear. Nevertheless, concussions, broken bones, and other injuries are frequent occurrences in professional football today.

In recent years, several athletes in the National Football League (NFL) have suffered injuries that could have resulted in paralysis or death. Such stars as Troy Aikman, Michael Irvin, and Steve Young were forced to retire after repeated hits resulted in serious concussions or spinal injuries.

This season, Pittsburgh Steelers quarterback Tommy Maddox suffered a severe concussion and a bruised spine during a game. Knocked unconscious, Maddox had to be taken by ambulance to a local hospital.

Such injuries, critics argue, prove that the NFL is not doing enough to protect its players. What do you think? Is pro football too violent?

YES

Any hit or tackle that leaves a player seriously injured is a form of violence. The NFL should ban certain hits, such as helmet-first tackles, that often cause concussions or career-ending injuries. Fans love the brutal action of a football game, but protecting players is more important.

"I think pro football is really violent," says Sean Pritchardthorpe, a seventh-grader at Mansfield Middle School in Mansfield, Connecticut. "Players like getting attention for hurting others and hitting hard, especially during the Super Bowl. I think the NFL should change its rules and stop players from getting hurt."

NO

Rules on how a player NO can hit and tackle another player would be impossible to enforce. For example, a player might be penalized, fined, or suspended for a clean hit that causes injury. Hard hits are part of the game, and pro football players are tough enough to take them.

"I don't think football is too violent," says Patrick Lanni, 11, a sixth-grader at Pierrepont School in Rutherford, New Jersey. "In football, a player is supposed to bring the opposing player down. You have to hit or tackle someone to get the ball back. You have to hit or tackle to stop a player from scoring."

Here's How You Voted

Our November 29, 2002, debate asked, "Should All Citizens Be Required to
Vote?" About 7,000 students voted on scholasticnews.com.

YES:  5,192
NO:   2,259

Note: Table made from pie chart

Source Citation

Source Citation   

Gale Document Number: GALE|A96376404